Genre: Mystery/Thriller
Premise: Ten years after she disappeared as a teen, Violet, now 25, turns up with no
memory of what happened to her, but as her family welcomes her home, it quickly
becomes apparent that the past cannot be forgiven or forgotten.
About: These two writers first hit the trades ten years ago with a script called Mayday 109. The logline was, “The story of how a young World War 2 Navy commander saved a group of men after their ship was destroyed by the Japanese. That man? John F. Kennedy.” They then went on to write Keeper of the Diary, about the attempt by Anne Frank’s father to sell her diary. This is their first high profile script I know about that is completely fictional.
Writers: Samuel Franco & Evan Kilgore
Details: 104 pages
Casey Affleck for Michael?
For the rest of this month, we’re going to be on a hunt. We’re going to be looking for scenes we can feature here on the site to work as inspiration for Scene Showdown. If you’re late to the party on Scene Showdown, here are the submission details.
What: Scene Showdown
Rules: Scene must be 5 pages or less
When: Friday, March 28
Deadline: Thursday, March 27, 10pm Pacific Time
Submit: Script title, Genre, 50 words setting up the scene (optional), pdf of the scene
Where: carsonreeves3@gmail.com
The fact that I couldn’t find a single scene from Sunday night’s episode of White Lotus, a show that hails from the best writer in television, is a reminder of just how difficult writing scenes is. I don’t think screenwriters think about it nearly enough. They think about their overall story then piece together a series of 1-2 page moments that, eventually, lead them to the conclusion of that story. But they don’t construct individual scenes unto themselves, scenes that have clear beginnings, middles, and ends.
It’s an epidemic and has become so common that I don’t think most writers even know how to write a scene anymore. I really don’t.
But I still go into every script hoping they do because I know that I’m going to have a much more enjoyable experience if they’re great scene-writers. So, let’s check it out!
Recently separated 36 year-old Michael Miller is going camping with his 14 year-old daughter, Violet. It’s going to be the last time they spend together for a while, as Violent will be going to live with her mom, Joanne.
Late at night, on the drive back from camping, Michael is stopped by a cop for speeding. The cop checks both Michael’s and Violet’s IDs, then request Violet get out of the car. Michael freaks out and tries to stop him but the cop threatens him with a gun. The cop then arrests Violet for distributing drugs, detains her in his car, and drives away. Michael tries to follow the cop but loses him.
When he finally makes it to the local police station, they say they don’t know this cop. After a few calls to other departments, they realize that the cop who picked Violet up was a fraud. Violet has been kidnapped.
Cut to 10 years later and Michael gets a shocking call. His daughter has been picked up in Mexico. Michael and Joanne head down there and retrieve their daughter, who has amnesia brought on by PTSD. The cops say to give her time. Her memory will come back.
(Things start getting spoilery from here on out)
When they get back to the U.S., a female detective named Manuela Garcia is assigned to cross the t’s and dot the i’s on the case. But she’s immediately suspicious that something is off regarding Violet. She’s particularly skeptical of the Mexcian cops, who refuse to send over the DNA test.
So Manuela goes down to Mexico to ask some questions. She immediately confirms that her suspicions were correct. This chick is definitely not Violet. But then who is she? And, more importantly, what happened to the real Violet? Manuela heads back to the U.S. to answer that question once and for all. But neither she, nor we, are prepared for what she discovers.
Okay, I got good news for you. WE’VE GOT SCENE WRITERS!
We get a fairly good one right away and then a really good one afterwards. That is the scene I’m pasting here. The setup is that this car has been riding Michael’s ass at night for a long time. Finally, Michael gets pissed and speeds away from it. As soon as he does, cop lights appear on the car, indicating it’s a cop, and he pulls them over.
This scene is an example of how classical situations can result in great scenes. Cops pulling you over create an immediate baseline of conflict that you can take in a lot of different directions in the scene. The trick with familiar scenarios is to build in your own unique details.
For example, this wasn’t a normal “cop pullover” scene. The cop baited them into breaking the law. It tricked them. So, already, we’re (the reader) more heated than we would usually be in this scenario because we know this cop is a snake.
From there, we have our clear beginning, middle, and end. To find your beginning, middle, and end, find the goal. That’s where you build your scene from. The goal doesn’t need to come from you hero. It can come from the villain. That’s the case here. The villain, the cop, wants the girl. That’s his goal. Now he just needs to execute his plan.
The middle of every story is your conflict section. It’s no fun if the person with the goal achieves that goal easily. There’s got to be pushback. We get that here in Michael and Violet resisting (and freaking out).
The highlight of this scene is something we don’t often talk about in scenes which is REVELATIONS. Revelations are great ways to pump up a scene, especially one that’s already cooking, like this one. The cop makes Violet get out of the car instead of Michael and then arrests her for drug-dealing (something that was vaguely set up in an earlier scene). We don’t know WHAT’S HAPPENING here. This was not expected. Which is why we’re so charged up.
That leads to the final act of the scene – the ending. This is the climax, where Michael tries to fight back, demanding answers. But the cop is able to hurry out of there and Michael isn’t able to get back on the road fast enough to follow him.
Really good scene.
As for the rest of the script, it’s good! The problem this particular story poses for writers is that, usually, all the best stuff happens in the first act. The girl goes missing. We cut to 10 years later where she reappears.
But then where is the story engine from that point on? Why would we keep reading? To see Michael, Joanne, and Violet have a series of awkward conversations for 90 minutes? You need something to drive the story. Kilgore and Franco achieve that by shifting the goal over to Detective Manuela.
She takes the reins and becomes the story engine – first looking to confirm that this is Violet and then trying to figure out what happened to Violent. In that sense, it’s a very well-written screenplay.
[major hints at spoiler below]
The climax of Vanished is the biggest whopper on this year’s Black List. I haven’t read 80% of the scripts yet but I know that’s the case. Cause this ending is a big swing. Does it work? It does! But is it perfect? No. It’s ALMOST there but not quite. If it got there, I would give this an impressive. But it was still darn close. And I appreciate the creative swing with the ultra twist ending. :)
[ ] What the hell did I just read?
[ ] wasn’t for me
[xx] worth the read
[ ] impressive
[ ] genius
What I learned: A simple way to improve your scene-writing is to set up stuff BEFORE THE SCENE. Then pay it off in the scene. One of the things you see happen in this scene is that Michael’s car won’t start. That ends up being the reason the cop gets away from him. This was set up a couple of times in earlier scenes. That this car was not top quality and was definitely on the unpredictable end. That setup allowed for the climax of the scene to be even more exciting.
