A couple of weeks ago, I saw a Christopher Nolan interview where he said that Ben Safdie and Nathan Fielder’s show, “The Curse” had no comp in television history. It was *that* unique. Combine this with an overall frustration in how bad television has been lately and I was seriously considering giving The Curse a chance. Why was I resistant to do so in the first place? Let’s check the tape, shall we? That is correct. I gave The Curse the lowest rating a Scriptshadow-reviewed pilot can get. A “what the hell did I just read?”
So, what happened between then and now? How did The Curse become the first TV season I finished in over a year? Let’s find out.
If you have no idea what The Curse is, let me pitch the entire package to you. Benny Safdie is one half of the best new directing team since the Coen Brothers entered the filmmaking scene. Bennie and his brother, Josh, made two of my favorite indie movies of the past decade, Good Time and Uncut Gems (Adam Sandler).
The directing duo were primed to take over Hollywood when Benny Safdie started pursuing an acting career. He was in the Obi-Wan show as well as Nolan’s Oppenheimer. His brother, Josh, started to get annoyed. And, just like that, the two canceled their next film together.
Benny befriended comedian Nathan Fielder, who is the king of awkwardness. His comedy is all about things being awkward and uncomfortable to watch. They came up with this idea when a homeless person said to them, “I curse you.” That sparked them to wonder, “What if that curse were real?”
They then did what everybody in Hollywood does when they have a new project – they go to the A-List. Everybody asks the A-List if they’ll do their movie (or show). And 999 times out of 1000, the A-Lister says no. But, to their shock, Emma Stone said yes. And all of sudden, they had a buzzy project on their hands.
The concept of the show is kind of complex so hang with me. A husband (Asher) and wife (Whitney) are making one of those HGTV shows. Whitney, whose parents are millionaire slum lords, is trying to erase the mark her parents have left on the world by doing the opposite of them.
Using their money, she buys out a lot of real estate land in a poor remote California community in order to build “passive energy” houses. Passive energy means that the house uses no energy whatsoever. It has zero imprint on the planet.
Whitney is determined to use the local Native American community to bless these homes and decorate them, particularly with local Native American art. All Whitney cares about is being good to the community and making up for the horrors that white people have put others through over the centuries.
Don’t worry. This show is not woke. It’s actually making fun of woke people. Whitney is a parody. In reality, she doesn’t care about these people at all. She cares about the way it makes her feel to “right” these “wrongs.” It’s purely selfish, although she’s not self-aware enough to realize this.
Asher, meanwhile is the beta “nice-guy” husband who, deep down, understands that his wife has gone way too far with all of this. But he’s so infatuated with her and holds her up on such a high pedestal, that he just goes along with all of it. He thinks, as long as I do what she says, she’ll stay with me.
Benny Safdie (Dougie) plays their showrunner. Dougie is destroyed by a fatal drunk driving accident he was involved in years ago. This has made him unable to fully cope with the world. He’s also kinda weird and acts odd at times. But, in the end, he just wants this job to keep going so he can get paid.
The “curse” part happens in the first episode. Asher gives a little homeless girl money for the show (so it can be captured on camera). He then takes it back after the camera stops filming, and that’s when the little girl looks him deep in the eyes and says, “I curse you.” This makes its way into the story because when things start falling apart for Whitney and Asher, he wonders if it’s because they’ve been cursed.
So, why did I change my tune on my “What The Hell Did I Just Read” rating?
Just like Christopher Nolan said, this is unlike anything you’ve watched before. And for someone like me, who’s watched everything, that’s exciting. Cause boy do Safdie and Fielder push the limits of subverting expectations.
I’ve never seen a show or a movie where the writers will purposefully set something up to deliberately not pay it off. I see bad writers do this all the time. But the reason they don’t pay their setups off is because they’re either too lazy or forgot about it.
Safdie and Fielder do it for a different reason: To ensure that the viewer has NO IDEA what’s coming next. They want you twisted and turned and upside-down so that they are always in control of how the story arrives in your brain.
Even casual TV watchers will be 30 minutes ahead of an average episode of television these days. They’ve seen too much TV. So they know where you’re going.
But that never happens here.
One of these setups is Dougie’s drug-driving backstory. In order to make sure he doesn’t drive drunk again, Dougie always carries a digital breathalyzer in his glove compartment. We see him, time and time again, take the breathalyzer out while he’s driving, blow on it, and then check the results – which usually come back close, but never over, the limit.
Safdie and Fielder will then spend an inordinate amount of time in the car, in silence, with Dougie driving at night, and we just KNOW that a car crash is coming. Cause it has to come, right? We get so many setup scenes to let us know it’s coming.
But it never does.
That singular subplot is the poster child of how this show works. We, the viewer, are being yanked around and played with. We can’t figure out where the story is going so we stop trying.
Another thing this show does a bang-up job of is scene-writing. When I tell you guys how important scene-writing is, the point I’m always trying to make is that a scene should be able to entertain you on its own. It shouldn’t just be a vessel to set up later plot elements.
Every scene here is entertaining on its own. And not in the way you’d expect. Safdie and Fielder do this unique thing where they try to create the most awkward situation and then make you sit in it.
Not for a few seconds. But a few minutes. They really sit you down and don’t let you escape the second-hand embarrassment, the awkwardness, the frustration you have for the characters on screen. Almost every scene is built like this and I’m not sure I’ve ever seen it before. It’s so unique that it’s almost like its own language.
For example, there are multiple scenes where Whitney, who’s just an awkward person in general, is desperately trying to befriend Cara, a local young Native American artist. Whitney wants Cara to be the face of the art in her renovation of this community.
But Cara sees Whitney for who she is. She’s a fake. She’s pretending to care. But all she really cares about is feeling good about herself. So Cara is having a hard time signing the rights away to her art so it can be on the show. She keeps putting off signing that waiver. The problem is, 70% of the show has already been shot and Cara’s art is everywhere. So Whitney really needs her to sign that waiver.
We then get this scene where Whitney comes over to Cara’s to pin her down and finally get the signature. Whitney is avoiding being pushy because she wants to be friends with Cara (as well as not ‘exploit’ her as a white person). Cara is trying to be cordial as she continually changes the subject whenever the request to sign the waiver is made.
Safdie and Fielder WILL NOT LET YOU OUT of this totally uncomfortable dance between these two. They sit in the awkwardness way longer than you’re comfortable with and, by the end, you’re crawling out of your skin.
There are 4-5 of those scenes in EVERY episode. These guys are brilliant at it.
Now, you may have heard some rumblings about the final episode of The Curse and its “WTF” climax. I’m not going to spoil it for anyone. But, keeping in line with what I said earlier – it is impossible to predict. I tried to predict it. But I was nowhere close. That, alone, is reason to celebrate this show. When have you ever watched anything where you could take 50 guesses at what will happen in the final episode and not come close with any of them? I don’t think that’s ever happened before.
With that said, this is still not in the same league as White Lotus. The writing does get loosey-goosey at times due to the fact that the narrative and writing-style are so odd. But the good stuff still outweighs the weak stuff by a wide margin.
I don’t know if I would recommend this to a casual viewer – like a family member. But I recommend it to everybody who reads this site because it teaches writers how to stay ahead of the reader. It teaches you how to make offbeat choices. It teaches you to always question whether you’re being too obvious the moment a major plot beat comes up. And it teaches you how to write characters into very uncomfortable situations. It does this last part better than any movie or show in history.
Be sure to let me know what you think once you’ve watched it. :)
[ ] What the hell did I just watch?
[ ] wasn’t for me
[ ] worth the watch
[x] impressive
[ ] genius
